Da Nicola Menu

If you’re curious about what makes this neighborhood favorite so special, the Da Nicola Menu is the perfect place to start. Tucked along 1203 Broadway in Hewlett, NY 11557, this spot brings that comforting, old-school Italian vibe straight to your table. The menu feels thoughtfully put together, balancing classic staples with dishes that keep things interesting.

You’ll find all the familiar comforts-crispy calamari, hearty pasta plates, and rich, slow-simmered sauces that taste like they’ve been perfected over generations. Then there are the pizzas, bubbling out of the oven with golden crusts and generous toppings, plus seafood options that feel both fresh and indulgent. Even the simple dishes seem to carry extra care, whether it’s a perfectly dressed salad or a creamy risotto that hits just right.

Everything reads like it was designed for sharing, lingering, and going back for “just one more bite,” which honestly feels like the whole point of dining here.

Appetizers

Baked Clams Oreganata
US$13.95
Sauteed Artichoke Hearts Oreganata
US$13.95
Fried Calamari
US$16.95
Fried Calamari Arabiatta
Crispy calamari sautéed in a spicy tomato sauce with hot cherry peppers and onions
US$17.95
Fried Zucchini
US$10.95
Mozzarella, Tomato, Roasted Peppers
Drizzled in balsamic vinaigrette
US$14.95
Malcom's Bar Pie
Thin crust Margherita pizza
US$10.95
Shrimp Cocktail
US$15.95
Shrimp, Bacon & Gorgonzola
Shrimp sautéed in a white wine sauce topped with bacon and gorgonzola and served with asparagus
US$16.95

Salads

House Salad
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumber, pimento, balsamic vinaigrette
US$8.95
Caesar Salad
Hearts of romaine, Parmesan, croutons, creamy homemade Caesar dressing
US$11.95
Shaved Vegetable Salad
Heirloom carrots, cucumbers, red onions, red peppers, shaved fennel, cauliflower, shaved radishes, lemon olive oil, and pumpkin seed with shaved Parmesan
US$13.75
Wedge Salad
Iceberg wedge, fresh tomatoes, crispy bacon, creamy gorgonzola dressing
US$14.95
Goat Cheese Salad
Mixed greens, craisins, candied walnuts, goat cheese, creamy honey balsamic
US$12.95
Avocado Salad
Hass avocados, English cucumber, red onions, almonds, imported feta cheese, tomatoes, olive oil, and balsamic
US$15.95
Arugula Salad
Fresh arugula, shaved Parmesan, lemon vinaigrette
US$11.95

Pastas

Whole Wheat Penne and Chicken Meatballs
Served in a tomato sauce
US$23.95
Gnocchi Alla Jay
Fresh gnocchi served with shrimp in a pesto vodka sauce
US$25.95
Trofie with Lump Crab, Shrimp & Panko Marechiaro
US$29.95
Handmade Fusilli with Braised Short Rib
US$25.95
Pappardelle Bolognese
Homemade pappardelle pasta in a veal meat sauce
US$23.95
Seafood Linguini
Shrimp, clams, calamari with a plum tomato sauce
US$32.95
Penne Alla Vodka
US$21.95
Whole Wheat Penne Primavera
Whole wheat penne tossed with sautéed seasonal vegetables served in a marinara or white wine sauce
US$18.95
Craig's Grilled Chicken Arabiatta with Whole Wheat Penne
Seasoned grilled chicken served over whole wheat penne in a spicy tomato sauce with hot cherry peppers and onions
US$23.95
Penne, Tomato & Basil
US$18.95
Penne, Tomato & Basil with Fresh Mozzarella
US$21.95
Zucchini Noodles with Shrimp Marinara
US$27.95
Orecchiette with Broccoli Rabe and Sausage
US$24.95

Entrees

Half Roasted Chicken
Crispy, oven-roasted chicken served with sautéed seasonal vegetables
US$23.95
Chicken Scarcella
Broiled chicken on the bone with roasted peppers, potatoes, garlic, and sausage, also available off the bone with white meat but must be specified.
US$29.95
Chicken Calabrese
Sautéed, topped with baked eggplant, melted mozzarella, and tomato in a sherry wine sauce with mushrooms
US$24.95
Chicken & Shrimp Italiano
Served with sundried tomatoes, mushrooms, and onions in a sherry wine sauce
US$28.95
Spicy Garlic Shrimp
Jumbo shrimp sautéed with garlic and spinach in a hot garlic and chili oil sauce
US$29.95

Italian Classics

Francese Italian Classic
Egg battered and sautéed in a lemon wine sauce
US$24.95
Montecassino Italian Classic
Sautéed, topped with baked eggplant and melted mozzarella, served in a sherry wine sauce with mushrooms
US$24.95
Parmigiano Italian Classic
Golden fried, topped with tomato sauce and melted mozzarella
US$24.95
Marsala Italian Classic
Sautéed in a Marsala wine sauce with mushrooms
US$24.95
Pizziola Italian Classic
Medallions of veal or chicken sautéed in red plum tomato sauce with mushrooms, peppers, and onions
US$24.95
Bruschetta Italian Classic
Pounded and breaded, topped with fresh arugula, chopped tomato, and onion salad
US$24.95
Uncle Hal's Italian Classic
With prosciutto and shoestring potato fries, in a wine sauce
US$24.95

Steaks and Chops

Skirt Steak
16 oz. grilled, marinated skirt steak
US$45.95
Grilled Ribeye
24 oz. black Angus bone-in ribeye
US$68.95
16 Oz. Prime Sirloin
US$62.95
Porkchops
Grilled pork chops served with hot cherry peppers and sautéed onions
US$29.95
10 Oz. Burger
Served with French fries. (Main Streets 1946 blend)
US$20.95

Seafood

Halibut
In a lemon caper sauce over mashed potatoes
US$37.95
Francese Seafood
Sautéed in a lemon, butter sauce
US$28.95
Arturo Seafood
Sautéed with fresh tomatoes, mushrooms, and onions
US$28.95
Broiled Seafood
In white wine and garlic butter
US$28.95
Oreganata Seafood
Broiled and topped with seasoned breadcrumbs
US$28.95
Livornese Seafood
Plum tomato sauce with olives, capers, and onions
US$28.95
Marechiaro Seafood
Light tomato sauce served with whole clams
US$33.90

Soups

Pasta Fagioli Soup
White beans and pasta in a light, plum tomato broth
US$8.95
Stracciatella Soup
Spinach and egg drop soup
US$8.95

Sides

Mixed Seasonal Vegetables
US$7.95
Roasted Potatoes
US$7.95
Mashed Potatoes
US$7.95
French Fries
US$5.95
Chicken Meatballs
US$9.95
Sautéed Spinach
US$7.95
Sautéed Broccoli
US$7.95
Sautéed Broccoli Rabe
US$9.95
Grilled Burnt Broccoli
US$9.95
Asparagus
US$9.95
Ready to order? Kerbside pickup, delivery and dine-in are all available. 📞 +1 516-812-5155